Impact of Monetary Policy: Fixed Exchange Rates vs. Flexible Exchange Rates

Get the full solved assignment PDF of MECE-004 of 2023-24 session now.

Fixed Exchange Rates:

Interest Rates: In a system of fixed exchange rates, central banks often adjust interest rates to maintain the currency’s peg. Higher interest rates can attract foreign capital, supporting the fixed rate but potentially dampening domestic economic activity.
Inflation Control: The focus is often on defending the exchange rate peg. If inflationary pressures arise, the central bank might need to tighten monetary policy to prevent the currency from depreciating.
Trade Balance: A fixed exchange rate can impact the trade balance. To maintain the peg, the central bank may intervene in currency markets, affecting money supply and potentially influencing exports and imports.
Limited Flexibility: The fixed exchange rate constrains the central bank’s ability to pursue independent monetary policies, as it must prioritize maintaining the peg.

Flexible Exchange Rates:

Interest Rates: Central banks have more flexibility to set interest rates based on domestic economic conditions without the need to defend a specific exchange rate. This can be used to address inflation or support economic growth.
Inflation Control: With flexible rates, central banks can focus on domestic inflation targets. Monetary policy can be tailored to address inflationary or deflationary pressures independently of the exchange rate.
Trade Balance: Exchange rate movements can influence trade balances. A depreciation may boost exports, while an appreciation may make imports cheaper. However, the impact on the trade balance is subject to various economic factors.
Policy Autonomy: Central banks have greater autonomy to pursue independent monetary policies, responding to domestic economic conditions without the need to maintain a fixed exchange rate.

Overall Comparisons:

Shock Absorption: Flexible exchange rates provide a natural shock absorber, allowing the currency to adjust to economic shocks. Under fixed rates, adjustments may be delayed, leading to potential imbalances.
Speculative Pressures: Fixed rates can face speculative pressures, especially if the peg is perceived as unsustainable. Flexible rates may mitigate speculative attacks as currencies can adjust based on market forces.
Global Economic Conditions: In a world with integrated financial markets, both fixed and flexible exchange rate systems are influenced by global economic conditions. However, flexible rates may allow for more independent responses to local economic challenges.

In summary, the impact of monetary policy under fixed exchange rates is often constrained by the need to defend the peg, whereas flexible exchange rates provide more room for independent monetary policy decisions tailored to domestic economic conditions. Each system has its advantages and challenges, and the choice between them depends on a country’s economic goals and circumstances.