Critically examine the relative merits and demerits of the fixed and flexible exchange rates

The choice between fixed and flexible exchange rates in an international monetary system has been a subject of debate among economists.

Get the full solved assignment PDF of MEC-007 of 2023-24 session now.

Each system comes with its own merits and demerits. Let’s critically examine the relative advantages and disadvantages of fixed and flexible exchange rates:

Fixed Exchange Rates:

Merits:

1. Stability: Fixed exchange rates provide stability and predictability for international trade and investment. This stability can be beneficial for businesses planning long-term investments.
2. Inflation Control: Fixed exchange rates can help control inflation by limiting the discretion of monetary authorities. The commitment to a fixed rate often necessitates responsible monetary policies.
3. Reduced Speculation: Fixed rates can reduce currency speculation since there is less uncertainty about future exchange rate movements. This can contribute to financial market stability.

Demerits:

1. Lack of Adjustment: Fixed rates limit the ability of countries to use exchange rates as an adjustment mechanism in response to economic shocks. This can lead to prolonged periods of economic imbalances.
2. Deflationary Pressures: In an attempt to maintain the fixed rate, countries may face deflationary pressures, especially if they need to keep interest rates high to defend their currency.
3. Vulnerability to External Shocks: Fixed exchange rates make countries vulnerable to external shocks, as they may need to adjust their domestic policies to maintain the fixed rate, which can be challenging in the face of changing global economic conditions.

Flexible Exchange Rates:

Merits:

1. Automatic Adjustment: Flexible exchange rates allow for automatic adjustment to changing economic conditions. Countries can use exchange rate movements to address trade imbalances and external shocks.
2. Monetary Policy Independence: Countries with flexible exchange rates have more flexibility in implementing independent monetary policies. This can be crucial for addressing domestic economic conditions.
3. Shock Absorption: Flexible rates provide a shock-absorbing mechanism, allowing countries to better cope with external economic disturbances without resorting to drastic domestic policy measures.

Demerits:

1. Uncertainty: The main criticism of flexible rates is the uncertainty they introduce for international trade and investment. Exchange rate volatility can create challenges for businesses planning investments or engaging in international trade.
2. Speculation: Flexible rates can attract speculative activities, leading to exaggerated currency movements that may not necessarily reflect fundamental economic factors.
3. Coordination Issues: Frequent and unpredictable exchange rate movements can complicate international economic coordination and create challenges for multinational businesses and policymakers.

In conclusion, the choice between fixed and flexible exchange rates involves trade-offs. Fixed rates provide stability but limit adjustment mechanisms, while flexible rates allow for adjustment but introduce uncertainty. The merits and demerits depend on the specific economic conditions, policy goals, and the ability of countries to manage their economies effectively within the chosen system.