Differentiate between activated sludge process and trickling bed filter

The activated sludge process and trickling filter (or trickling bed filter) are two common methods used for the biological treatment of wastewater in sewage treatment plants.

Get the full solved assignment PDF of MEV-015 of 2023-24 session now.

They differ in their configurations, mechanisms of biological treatment, and the structures used for the treatment process.

Activated Sludge Process:

1. Configuration:

• Tank System: The activated sludge process typically involves aeration tanks where wastewater is mixed with a microbial culture (activated sludge) in a suspended state.
• Settling Tank: Following the aeration tank, the mixture is allowed to settle in a secondary clarifier to separate the treated water from the activated sludge.

1. Treatment Mechanism:

• Biological Treatment: Microorganisms in the activated sludge aerobically consume organic pollutants in the wastewater, breaking them down into simpler, less harmful substances.
• Aeration: The process relies on the continuous introduction of air into the aeration tank to maintain aerobic conditions for microbial activity.

1. Advantages:

• Effective for High-Strength Wastewater: Suitable for treating wastewater with high organic loads.
• Flexible Design: Can adapt to variations in influent flow and load.

1. Challenges:

• Sludge Management: Requires the management and disposal of excess activated sludge generated during the process.
• Energy Consumption: Aeration demands energy for maintaining optimal oxygen levels.

Trickling Filter (Trickling Bed Filter):

1. Configuration:

• Fixed-Film System: Trickling filters consist of a circular or rectangular tank filled with a medium, often made of plastic, rock, or other materials. Wastewater is distributed over the surface of the medium, creating a thin film.
• Tank Design: The medium provides a substrate for the growth of microbial biofilm.

1. Treatment Mechanism:

• Biological Treatment: Microorganisms attached to the surface of the medium form a biofilm. As wastewater trickles over the biofilm, the microorganisms metabolize organic pollutants in the water.
• Air Circulation: Natural or forced air circulation provides oxygen to the biofilm.

1. Advantages:

• Low Energy Consumption: Requires less energy compared to the activated sludge process due to the reliance on natural processes.
• Reduced Sludge Production: Generates less excess sludge compared to the activated sludge process.

1. Challenges:

• Vulnerability to Upset: Sensitive to hydraulic and organic load variations, and may be prone to upsets.
• Limited in Treating High-Strength Wastewater: May not be as effective for treating wastewater with high organic loads.

Key Differences:

1. Treatment Mechanism:

• Activated Sludge: Suspended microbial culture in the water.
• Trickling Filter: Microbial biofilm attached to a fixed medium.

1. Tank Configuration:

• Activated Sludge: Aeration tanks with suspended sludge.
• Trickling Filter: Tanks filled with a medium for biofilm growth.

1. Energy Consumption:

• Activated Sludge: Requires energy for aeration.
• Trickling Filter: Generally consumes less energy.

1. Sludge Production:

• Activated Sludge: May produce more excess sludge.
• Trickling Filter: Typically generates less excess sludge.

Both processes aim to achieve biological treatment, but the choice between them depends on factors such as the characteristics of the influent wastewater, treatment goals, and the available resources at the treatment plant.